|Season 3, Episode 10|
|Air Date||Janurary 17, 2012|
"Extraordinary Merry Christmas"
Yes/No is the tenth episode of season three. It aired on January 17, 2012.
While singing The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face, Rachel remembers when she first saw Finnin the hallways of McKinley. In a later scene, Rachel, Finn and Kurt are at Breadstix, Finn sulks, and says, "Why can't I have anything in my life that's special or means something?" This leads Rachel to sing Without You very emotionally to Finn. At the end of the episode, Finn proposes to Rachel after a very passionate speech, telling Rachel that she helps him get through the darkness in this life. He was talking about the Football scholarship he didn't get, and him finding out earlier in the episode that his dad did not in fact die as a war-hero in Iraq as he thought, but from a drug overdose in Cincinnati. Rachel is left speechless, and the episode ends with her failing to give an answer.